What to order
Cob pizza (and a parmesan tomato pie)
DC's Pizza & Catering · Albany
Its online slice menu lists cob pizza with the mozzarella under the sauce, plus a separate tomato pie.
Last checked Aug 17, 2026 · Call ahead
Dishes /
Start with a dish
Tomato pie
A thick bakery square, mostly tomato, little or no mozzarella, often eaten at room temperature.
Out
What to order
Tomato pie
Perreca's Bakery · Schenectady
Schenectady's Little Italy bakery square: tomato-forward, room temperature, no mozzarella blanket.
Last checked Aug 17, 2026 · Call ahead
What to order
Tomato pie
Civitello's Italian Pastry Shoppe · Schenectady
Same block as Perreca's. The official menu lists tomato pie Tuesday through Saturday.
Tomato pie listed Tue–Sat (official menu)
Last checked Aug 17, 2026 · Call ahead
What to order
Tomato pie
West Avenue Pizzeria · Saratoga Springs
Sauce, grated parmesan and olive oil, listed separately from the upside-down square.
Last checked Sep 7, 2026 · Call ahead
What to order
Tomato pie
Roma Sausage & Deli · Utica
Utica bakery-deli tomato pie. Morning hours, and it often sells out.
Last checked Aug 17, 2026 · Call ahead
What to order
Tomato pie
Roma Sausage & Deli · New Hartford
The second Roma shop, same tomato pie.
Last checked Aug 17, 2026 · Call ahead
Home
House recipe
Bakery-style tomato pie, home version
The Schenectady bakery square, made in a sheet pan. Mostly tomato, a little cheese, good at room temperature.
Cook it, with farm stops for the ingredients →